Step 1: Seafood ... Now, my basic rule for this sandwich is approximately 1/2 lobster (2 cups, or 12-14 oz lobster meat); and, the rest can filled filled up with any other seafood you like. I usually pick one or two other type of seafood, to mix with the lobster. Crab and Cod are two of my favorites; shrimp and scallops are also a nice mix. You just want to end up with 3 3/4-4 cups of of cooked seafood. Half, or more of it being the lobster.
Step 2: Note: Lobster, shrimp, and crab you can get pre-cooked at most fish markets or grocery store counters. Scallops and fish you would have to cook yourself.
Step 3: Fish and Scallops ... The easiest method for this, is a quick poach. A little water, (1") in a small saute pan; and, bring to a light boil. Add the fish or scallops, reduce to medium low, and cover. Simmer until firm. Scallops only take 2-3 minutes per side. Cod, which is quite thick, can take up to 5 minutes on the first side; and, maybe 3-4 on the second side. I often cut the fish into large 1 1/2-2" cubes; it tends to cook quicker, and easier to keep an eye on as well. Transfer to a plate to cool. And, make sure, that all the seafood is completely cooled before adding it to the dressing. Once cooled, rough chop.
Step 4: Again, you can add crab, shrimp, fish, or scallops to the lobster. Use your favorite. My favorite happens to be Cod, and sometimes a few scallops.
Step 5: Salad ... In a medium bowl, mix the mayonnaise, lemon juice (start with 1 tablespoon, you can always add more), scallions, hot sauce, old bay, salt, and pepper. Then, mix to combine. Make sure to taste. Then, add your seafood; gently folding it in with the dressing. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate until well chilled - approximately 1 hour.
Step 6: Butter and Buns ... In a measuring cup or small bowl, melt the butter in the microwave. Just 1 minute or less on medium low heat. Brush the butter on the inside of the hot dog rolls/buns and add to a grill pan or saute pan until VERY lightly golden brown. The broiler is not the best method for this. You don't want them, crusty; you want them soft and buttery. Now - traditionally, they use a potato hot dog style type of roll, cut from the top; not the side cut - more traditional hot dog buns. Many stores and bakeries will make them for you, if you just ask. But, a classic hot dog bun will work fine.
Step 7: Serve ... Number 1 rule: Make sure the salad is chilled, and the bun is warm and buttery. I like to add a few lettuce leaves to the bottom of the roll (not traditional); but, I enjoy it. Then, STUFF with the salad and enjoy! And, make sure not to skimp. Worthy of company or a dinner party. ENJOY!
This page is built for your convenience in the kitchen.
If you want helpful tools, tips and recipes from our community of real cooks, please consider signing up.
Oh... And one more thing... We also have some pretty wild forums.